The world today is actively becoming more
globalized and technologically dependent as every day passes. This is a world
where information regarding anything is a mere Google away
and a world where people's opinions are so influenced by media and authority figures. Luckily those that seek the truth on matters with logic and
reason are rather apt at acquiring credible knowledge on whatever it may be
they wonder about.
It seems that our society happens to be the opposite
of the world in Plato's Allegory of
the Cave, available here. However, the film The Matrix starring the ever-curious Keanu
Reeves as the hero and seeker of real knowledge provides an excellent modern
day example of Socrates's idea of the cave and its blinding affects on true
perception. The Matrix is a film that follows a skilled hacker called Neo who is educated about the reality of the world he lives in by a group of mysterious and leather loving rebels run by a man named Morpheus. Morpheus is convinced that Neo is the key to ending the enslavement of the human race by the "machines," which are machines equipped with artificial intelligence and the power to control humans. After the machines won a cataclysmic war against the humans, the machines were forced to enslave the human race and use our bodies to harvest electricity while keeping us in an engineered alternate reality called the matrix, which resembles current modern day society.
![]() |
| Red or Blue: Make a Pick, Change Your Life |
The scene that best represents and most quickly explains the relationship of the world in The Matrix and the cave is the pill scene, seen here. Morpheus explains to Neo that world created by the machines, the matrix, is "the world that has been pulled over you eyes to blind you from the truth"; a constructed world much like the cave where the inhabitants "have been from their childhood, and have their legs and necks chained so that they cannot move, and can only see before them, being prevented by the chains from turning round their heads." Neo is very much like those sorry souls watching the shadows on the wall of the cave; Neo and the prisoners are as Morpheus says "born into bondage; born into a prison that you cannot smell or taste or touch; a prison for your mind." Both Neo and the prisoners of the cave are perpetually imprisoned by their ignorance of the real world and are consequentially ill-suited in understanding the real world when they are actually given the ability to see it.
Once those kept in the dark are enlightened, a philosophical
debate arises over the ethical obligation of sharing this newfound knowledge
with those around. Those from the cave who see the real world and return are
compelled to share their experiences with their peers in order to give
their peers a sense of the amazement that is outside the cave. Also, it may be in
attempts to further reaffirm in themselves what they just experienced. Socrates say that these enlightened few would "consider himself happy for the change and pity the others." However
unlike those in the cave, Neo is unable to share his knowledge of the real world because the matrix is so effective in convincing everyone that the world they live in is reality. As such, Neo's only choice in resolving this is by putting an end to the machines' exploitation of the human race without being able to garner support through sharing his experience of the world outside the matrix with the uninformed masses.
![]() |
| BOMBSHELL |
Neo's choice to take the red pill and "stay in Wonderland" while seeing "how deep the rabbit hole goes" embodies Socrates's emphasis on the decision making process of enlightenment and how it affects other's views of those enlightened. In making this decision, as Socrates says, it is likely that "the men who get to that point aren’t willing to mind the business of human beings, but rather that their souls are always eager to spend their time above." Those who see the light of the real world are so amazed by the beauty and truth of their this world that their obligation to share it becomes compromised by the personal desire to be the only one experiencing it. This obligation is further complicated by the hypothesized reactions of those still in the cave as perceiving those who see the light "to come from acts of divine contemplation to the human evils, is graceless and looks quite ridiculous when...he is compelled in courts or elsewhere to contest about the shadows of the just or the representations of which they are the shadows, and to dispute about the way these things are understood by men who have never seen justice." It is awfully difficult to explain someone the truth when they are not willing or able to believe it.
I agree most with what Socrates say about education and the availability of it in everyone. Socrates posits that "this power is in the soul of each, and that the instrument with which each learns...must be turned around from that which is coming into being together with the whole soul until it is able to endure looking at that which is." This view of experience and education is something I am inclined to agree with. I am content to know that we all have the ability to challenge perceptions and change paradigms. It is a personal responsibility to ask questions you want to know the answer to. Neo's ability to do away with his old conventions of his constructed matrix life and his aptitude of embracing the new reality he faces affirm his character as a redeeming researcher who comes to save the world from ignorance. The importance of sharing information, pertinent or not, is fundamental to the livelihood of a modern society. Knowledge truly is power, and those without knowledge in today's world are becoming increasingly powerless.


ReplyDeleteI agree with John that the Matrix is a great example of Platos' Allegory of the Cave. The scene where Neo is forced to choose between two pills, red or blue, resembles the beginning of a new life. This new life that Neo is able to choose is similar to the "Allegory of the Cave" because Neo is now exposed to a new dimension that he never experienced before. He was once living in the Matrix which is a fictional computer program in which everything is controlled by the key master. Neo lives in a sense of two dimensions and is exposed to a whole new life and civilization that he did not know existed. His tritons and culture is also slightly different.
I think that this quote from Johns blog is a great point.
"The importance of sharing information, pertinent or not, is fundamental to the livelihood of a modern society. Knowledge truly is power, and those without knowledge in today's world are becoming increasingly powerless."
This quote is similar to the Matrix because Neo left the world he once knew behind him and he was not able to explain or share the new information he learned with his fellow friends and family. Neo was the chosen one and gave up his old life for a new one. The statement that John makes about knowledge is profound. He states "Knowledge is truly power, and those without knowledge in today's world are becoming increasingly
Let me start by saying I enjoyed your post. The matrix is an excellent movie, and your comparison of it with "The Cave" is a great connection. It is so spot on that it brings up the question of whether the directors of the matrix are alluding to the cave. The scene with the pills epitomizes the decision of those in the cave. Given the opportunity do they stay in the cave, or go outside? if you asked Cypher he would say to stay inside the cave. There everything is easy, and there is no stress. If you asked anybody else, they would agree to leave the matrix, that way they could have the knowledge of the real world. Like "The Cave", unless of course you are Cypher, you pity those still confined in the matrix, and they do not understand why they should leave or change anything.
ReplyDeleteThe one thing that I thought of the whole time was the literal notion of seeing the sun. In "The Cave" the sun was a symbol for knowledge, and after seeing this knowledge somebody could never go back to "The Cave" or even reason with those who hadn't seen it themselves. If we broaden the scope of the post to the Matrix Trilogy, we can see this as well. The only time anybody sees the real sun in the movies is towards the end of the third movie, and Neo and Trinity fly through the storm clouds and come out in view of the sun. Immediately after this, Trinity is injured in such a way that she dies. And Neo follows suit soon after.